Grenoble, a Tuesday in February. Hugo puts a vibration sensor on his manager’s desk.
“A hundred and eighty euros. I stick it on a chairlift gearbox, and in three weeks I’ll know whether we can predict breakdowns before they happen.”
She looks at the device, then at her screen, then at Hugo.
“It’s a good idea. Put together a file for the investment committee. It meets in March.”
“For a hundred and eighty euros?”
“For a hundred and eighty euros. Purchasing doesn’t know your supplier.”
Hugo has been a maintenance technician for eleven years at a mid-sized ski-lift manufacturer in Savoie. He can recognize every gearbox by its sound. He will never put that file together. By March he will have forgotten, and the season will have brought its usual breakdown, the one that leaves eighty skiers stuck on a chairlift for forty minutes.
How many ideas like Hugo’s die every week in your company, for lack of a few hundred euros and an approval nobody has the power to give quickly?
Adobe tackled this problem more than ten years ago. Its answer fits in a red box.
A red box, a thousand dollars and a candy bar
If you walked around Adobe’s San Jose headquarters around 2015, you had a good chance of spotting red boxes sitting on desks (Fortune). The program is called Kickbox. It was designed by Mark Randall, then a vice president at Adobe, drawing on his own experience as an entrepreneur.
Inside the box: a $1,000 prepaid credit card, a Starbucks gift card, a candy bar and instructions for a six-step process (Fortune). Randall explains the sugar and caffeine with a wink: they are supposedly two of the innovator’s four basic food groups. You also find sticky notes, a small notebook for logging “bad ideas” and a timer for time-boxed brainstorming sessions.
The card is the core of it. It funds experiments with no expense report and no prior approval (Adobe Blog). No committee, no purchase order.
Another detail that matters: the box is open to every employee. You don’t need to be an engineer, or even to have an idea yet, to request one (Business Insider). Participants receive it during a two-day workshop (ITmedia).
Hugo would have had his sensor the same day.
Six levels to kill an assumption
People often reduce Kickbox to its $1,000. That misses how it works. The card pays for a journey, and the journey is demanding.
The process has six levels: Inception, Ideate, Improve, Investigate, Iterate and Infiltrate (The Next Web). Each comes with its own reference card and a checklist to complete before moving on.
- Inception questions motivation. Randall doesn’t care why you want to innovate, he only insists that it matters to you.
- Ideate trains you to produce and record ideas in large numbers.
- Improve asks you to structure the idea, notably with a dedicated canvas.
- Investigate forces you to test the idea with real customers, for example with a product website and a minimum number of visitors.
- Iterate evolves your hypotheses based on the results.
- Infiltrate prepares the pitch to management.
Those who complete level 6 receive funding to continue, and a second box, blue this time (Adobe Blog).
Look closely at the logic. For five levels out of six, the idea owner asks nobody for permission. They collect evidence. When they finally stand in front of management, they bring field data. Assumptions are highly dangerous, and the only way to kill them early is experimentation. Intuit calls this a meritocracy of ideas: only experimental results count, however eloquent the presenter (My book, chapter 11).
$1,000, the price of trust
Adobe’s finance department opposed the project. Understandably: handing out uncontrolled credit cards to hundreds of employees looks like a management failure.
Randall answered with a line that deserves to hang in every executive committee room: if you don’t trust an employee enough to give them $1,000 for an idea, you shouldn’t have hired them (ITmedia). According to him, out of roughly 1,300 participants, none had gone off to spend the money in Las Vegas. That figure comes from Randall himself and has not been independently audited. It still rings true.
Run the numbers in your own organization. The cost of preparing a file for an investment committee, counting the time of the person writing it, the people reviewing it and the committee members, very often exceeds a few hundred euros. You sometimes spend more deciding than trying.
The heaviest cost shows up in Hugo’s behavior, though. In large companies, 55% of the obstacles to innovation come from executives’ internal politics, turf wars and lack of alignment (My book, chapter 2). Hugo ran into a process designed to say no without ever saying it. He will draw a simple conclusion: around here, you keep your ideas to yourself.
When I break down this kind of blockage with the five whys method, the same root causes keep coming back: no time allocated, no budget for experimentation, and an idea that doesn’t fit the annual objectives (My book, chapter 5). The red box tackles the first two at once.
What others copied
In 2015 Adobe made the method freely available to every company (Adobe Blog). Several large groups picked it up and adapted it.
Swisscom was among the first. The Swiss operator gives each participant a starting budget of CHF 1,000, 20% of their working time for two months and a personal coach (rready). The company reports more than 500 ideas submitted and 27 ideas that reached the implementation stage. Those figures are published by rready, the Swisscom spin-off that now sells the Kickbox platform: keep that in mind when reading them.
Cisco drew on it to launch the Innovate Everywhere Challenge in 2015, open to all its employees. Participants received a lighter version of the box, called the Adventure Kit (Network World). Winning teams receive $25,000 in cash recognition, $25,000 in seed funding, mentoring and a three-month rotation to develop their project (Cisco Newsroom). After five editions, out of 85 semifinalist teams, 24 had been funded and 9 had become products (Cisco Blogs).
LinkedIn chose a different entry point. Every quarter, any employee can form a team and pitch their project to the executive staff. Approved projects get up to three months (LinkedIn Engineering). The program, called [in]cubator, was proposed by employees who had won several internal hackdays.
Before all this came free time: 3M with its 15%, Google with its 20%, Intuit with its “unstructured time.” At Intuit, every employee has a share of their time for projects outside the usual project management structure, as part of a three-horizon growth model (My book).
The trap of time on paper
Beware of a stubborn illusion. Time granted is worth nothing if it isn’t protected.
In 2008, Atlassian launched a “20% time” experiment for its developers. Given how many people actually took part, the time effectively spent came closer to 1.1% (Wikipedia). Urgent work ate the exploration.
The company kept a shorter, sturdier format: ShipIt Days, 24 hours per quarter to work on any project. That format produced hundreds of small process improvements, while free time produced fewer outcomes, but with larger impact (Computerworld).
Look at the funnels too. At Cisco, 9 products from 85 semifinalist teams works out to about 11%. Measured against the total number of ideas submitted, the rate becomes tiny. A company expecting immediate returns from these programs will be disappointed. Their first return shows up in behavior: employees who test instead of debating, managers who learn to read evidence.
A program boasting thousands of ideas and zero completed experiments is decoration. Measure before, during and after: number of tests run, time from idea to first customer contact, number of projects stopped based on data. A project stopped early is good news. It is money you won’t sink into a mediocre project.
What you can launch on Monday
No need to print red boxes. You need three things.
First, a modest individual budget, usable without approval. The amount matters less than removing the friction. The affordable loss principle from effectuation applies here: you set the maximum risk before acting, then you let people get on with it (My book, chapter 6).
Second, truly protected time, written into objectives, which managers are not allowed to requisition at the first fire.
Third, stages that you clear by bringing evidence. You move forward with customers met and tests run, whatever the quality of the slides.
Then ask yourself an uncomfortable question. On a scale of 0 to 5, how much does your organization trust its employees to spend €1,000 on an idea? If your answer is below 3, the problem probably sits above them.
Hugo ended up buying the sensor with his personal card. He installed it quietly, on a Saturday. He won’t tell anyone, and the company will never benefit from what he learned.
The essentials
Remember four things:
- Adobe’s Kickbox combines a $1,000 budget usable without approval and a six-level journey that forces you to test the idea with real customers.
- The money works first as a signal of trust and removes administrative friction.
- Free time granted without protection evaporates: at Atlassian, 20% shrank to about 1.1%.
- Effective programs combine budget, protected time and stages cleared on evidence.
Innovate or agonize: the choice is yours.
A corporate event, a seminar, an executive committee meeting, or a management committee meeting?
Philippe’s keynotes on innovation and AI are groundbreaking, you’ve been warned!
Complement a powerful keynote with innovative and impactful workshops.
A keynote inspires and raises awareness; workshops transform!
References
- (My book) https://philippeboulanger.com/book/
- (Fortune) https://fortune.com/2015/02/17/adobe-innovation/
- (Adobe Blog) https://blog.adobe.com/en/publish/2014/12/10/kickbox-interview
- (Adobe Blog) https://blog.adobe.com/en/publish/2015/02/09/kickbox-open-sourcing-makes-innovation-easily-accessible-for-all-companies
- (Business Insider) https://www.businessinsider.in/Adobe-just-gave-all-of-its-employees-a-1000-gift-card-with-basically-no-strings-attached/articleshow/47039705.cms
- (ITmedia) https://nlab.itmedia.co.jp/cont/articles/3248153/
- (The Next Web) https://thenextweb.com/news/will-adobes-kickbox-program-transform-good-ideas-into-popular-products-adobes-mark-randall-says-yes
- (rready) https://www.rready.com/blog/kickbox-success-story-infravista
- (rready) https://www.rready.com/swisscom-success-story
- (Network World) https://www.networkworld.com/article/3083436/cisco-unearths-its-inner-startup-culture-via-companywide-innovation-contest.html
- (Cisco Newsroom) https://newsroom.cisco.com/c/r/newsroom/en/us/a/y2019/m09/five-years-with-innovate-everywhere-challenge.html
- (Cisco Blogs) https://blogs.cisco.com/innovation/cheers-to-the-5th-anniversary-of-the-innovate-everywhere-challenge/
- (LinkedIn Engineering) https://engineering.linkedin.com/incubator/linkedin-incubator
- (Wikipedia) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/20%25_time
- (Computerworld) https://www.computerworld.com/article/2717494/stop-working-and-start-innovating–it-can-pay-off.html







