Guest Checkout: The Button That Lifted Sales by 45%

Rennes, France, a Tuesday in November, 9:40 p.m. Samuel, head of e-commerce at a home-linen retailer, is watching the same video for the third time. It is an anonymized recording of a customer session. A shopper has filled her cart: a duvet cover, two pillowcases, a throw. 286 euros. She clicks “Order.” The screen asks for her email address and password.

She types a first password. Rejected. A second one. Rejected. She clicks “Forgot password,” waits about forty seconds, switches to her email tab, comes back to the site. The cursor hovers over the “Create an account” button. Then the tab closes.

Samuel calls his CRM manager.

“How many carts do we lose on the login screen?”

“I don’t know exactly. We don’t measure that screen.”

“What if we dropped mandatory account creation?”

“Marketing will never agree. No account, no customer data.”

Samuel hangs up. He has just put his finger on a friction nobody in the company sees, because nobody measures it. And he wonders whether he is even allowed to touch a screen that several departments consider their own.

Samuel’s story is fictional. The one that follows is real, and it reportedly brought in 300 million dollars.

A form with two fields and two buttons

January 2009. Jared Spool, founder of the consulting firm User Interface Engineering, publishes a short article with a cheeky title: “The $300 Million Button” (Center Centre). He describes a project for a large online retailer he never names.

The form in question is utterly ordinary. Two fields: email address and password. Two buttons: “Login” and “Register.” A “Forgot Password” link. It appears right after shoppers click “Checkout,” before they enter payment details (Center Centre).

The designers thought they were helping. A registered customer buys faster next time, since addresses and payment details are already stored. On paper, the logic holds.

Spool’s team runs usability tests. Participants get money and a shopping list, with one simple instruction: buy. First-time shoppers reject registration. One of them sums up the discomfort: “I’m not here to enter into a relationship. I just want to buy something.” (Center Centre)

Returning customers can’t remember whether they have an account. They try combinations, fail, get annoyed. Many suspect registration is a way to flood them with marketing. The irony: the registration form asked only for name, shipping and billing addresses, and payment information. Exactly what was needed to deliver the order anyway (Center Centre).

What the database had been saying for years

What happened in the test lab could have been brushed aside. A few grumpy participants, a sample too small. So the team went to the data.

45% of customers had multiple registrations, some as many as ten. About 160,000 people requested a password reset every day. And 75% of those who requested one never completed a purchase (Center Centre).

Read those numbers again. The data had been sitting in the company’s servers since day one. Nobody had looked at it from that angle, because nobody was asking. The form had become part of the furniture.

This is what I call invisible friction. I describe friction as one of the two levers of any habit change: you increase desire, you remove friction. A buying habit follows the same rules. Every field to fill in is a toll the customer pays with attention. When the toll exceeds the desire, the customer turns around (My book, chapter 5).

This book is for CEOs, managers, and innovators ready to challenge everything and create exponential growth.

Be the first to get the english version!

A button, and above all a sentence

The fix was small. The designers removed the “Register” button. In its place, a “Continue” button, with a message: you don’t need an account to buy, and you can create one during checkout to make future purchases faster (Center Centre).

Everyone remembers the button. Everyone forgets the sentence. Yet the sentence does most of the work. It answers the customer’s fear before it is voiced, and it keeps the account by moving it after the purchase. Registration goes from entry barrier to option, offered once the customer has what they came for.

The reported result: the number of customers making a purchase jumped 45%, with an extra 15 million dollars in the first month and 300 million in the first year (TheDomains). Spool says he found a voicemail from the CEO of this 25-billion-dollar retailer the week the new sales figures came in (CMSWire).

Why that number should make you suspicious

I have said it often: assumptions are dangerous, and beautiful stories even more so. This one ticks every box of the perfect corporate fairy tale. A tiny fix, a big round number.

Look at it critically. The retailer is never named. The figures come from the consultant who ran the project, and seventeen years later nobody can cross-check them. Nothing says whether there was a control group, or how much of the increase came from the season, promotions or the growth of online retail. Online, the story has even mutated: some versions describe an A/B test or a third “guest” button added next to the other two, which the original article does not say (Atticus Li).

Should you throw the case away? No. Put it back where it belongs: solid on the mechanism, shaky on the amount. And the mechanism has since been measured by others. The Baymard Institute, which studies checkout usability, surveyed 1,026 US adults who had shopped online in the previous three months: 18% said they had abandoned an order because they did not want to create an account (Baymard). Other research from the same institute, reported by Amazon Pay, finds that forgotten passwords stop 19% of account holders from completing checkout (Amazon Pay).

Seventeen years on, the friction is still there. Companies that keep it are not short of information. They lack the reflex to go looking for it.

Why nobody touches that screen

Go back to Samuel. His CRM manager has a point: without accounts, the company collects less data. Marketing defends its customer file, sales defends its conversion rate. Everyone has a good reason, and the form stays.

This is the scenario I see in most organizations. A login screen belongs to everyone, so it belongs to no one. Changing it takes a cross-functional decision, and cross-functional decisions are the ones silos bury best. In large companies, internal politics and turf wars weigh heavily among the obstacles to innovation (My book, chapter 2).

Add status quo bias. What exists feels legitimate simply because it exists. Nobody ever got fired for leaving a form in place. The cost of doing nothing is invisible, it shows up on no dashboard. The cost of a failed change has a name and an owner.

Finally, there is a stubborn belief that innovation must involve heavy technology, R&D budgets, artificial intelligence. The $300 million button shows the opposite. No algorithm, no investment. A label, a reassuring sentence, and the courage to remove something.

What Samuel can do on Monday morning

If you are in Samuel’s shoes, here is the approach I recommend. It takes four steps.

Step one: measure before you touch anything. How many visitors reach the login screen, how many leave, how many request a new password, how many complete their purchase after that request. Without this baseline, you will prove nothing.

Step two: watch your customers. Five recorded sessions are often enough to break a certainty. Spool invented nothing brilliant. He watched people buy, then checked in the database what those observations suggested.

Step three: test on a slice of traffic. One version with guest checkout, the current version, and enough time for the result to owe nothing to chance. The A/B test is the simplest tool to kill an assumption before it kills your conversion.

Step four: make account creation an option offered after payment, as a single checkbox, with a concrete benefit such as order tracking or easier returns. You will recover part of the accounts, this time from customers who chose to open one.

And rate yourself honestly, on a scale of 0 to 5: how much are you subject to status quo bias when it comes to the screens you see every day? I am not always at 5 myself.

The essentials

Remember four things:

  • Friction is a hidden cost your customers pay first, and no standard dashboard shows it.
  • The $300 million figure cannot be verified, but recent cart-abandonment research confirms the mechanism.
  • The data that reveals friction often sits in your own servers, waiting for someone to query it.
  • Before removing a step, measure. After removing it, measure again.

Sometimes innovating means removing an obstacle everyone had stopped seeing. Innovate or agonize, the choice is yours!

References

Picture of Philippe Boulanger

Philippe Boulanger

Philippe Boulanger, international speaker on innovation and artificial intelligence, author, advisor, mentor and consultant.

Latest POSTS

Adobe Kickbox: $1,000 to Test an Idea Without Permission

At Adobe, any employee can receive a red box with $1,000 to spend without approval to test an idea. What’s inside, the six levels of the journey, what Swisscom, Cisco and LinkedIn took from it, and the trap of free time that evaporates.

Read More »

41 Shades of Blue: Google’s $200 Million A/B Test

By testing 41 shades of blue, Google claims it earned an extra $200 million a year. Behind the cult A/B testing anecdote lies a debate every leader has to settle: when to trust the data, and when it stops you from innovating.

Read More »

Drone vs Camera Robot: Who Films Where the Sky Is Banned?

Banned from flying over crowds, drones run into regulation and noise. The Beni camera robot films from the ground. A textbook case of the framing bias.

Read More »

Friday the 13th: why superstition pays off for innovators

Friday the 13th destroys nothing. People who fear it change their behavior, and that change can be measured. Accidents, stock markets, the Jerusalem virus, a $900 million figure nobody verified: what superstition reveals about your innovation decisions, and how to use it.

Read More »

Naming an innovation: what Sapir showed in 1929

In 1929, Edward Sapir showed that most people link the invented word “mal” to a large table and “mil” to a small one. Almost a century later, sound symbolism still shapes how we perceive product names. What the numbers really say, what marketing took from it, and how to test a name before you pick it.

Read More »

AI-Generated Code: Who Still Understands Your Software?

A year after handing 100% of its code to AI, a company finds that nobody can explain it anymore. An anonymous testimony, the METR, GitClear and Veracode studies, and the method to stay out of the labyrinth.

Read More »

Why Coca-Cola’s Inventor Never Got Rich

John Pemberton invented Coca-Cola in 1886 and died poor two years later. Thirty-three years after the first glass, the company was worth $25 million. What this story reveals about the difference between invention and innovation, and about the Pemberton who may be sitting in your own company.

Read More »

Rare-Earth-Free Motors: France Had a 14-Year Head Start

Renault has built rare-earth-free motors since 2012. Then the stator of its next E7A motor went to China. How a technological lead gets lost in purchasing trade-offs.

Read More »

Are you a rule breaker?

You weren’t supposed to find this.

But here you are, because you did what most people don’t: you questioned, you explored, you clicked the thing you weren’t sure you should click.

That’s Innovational Intelligence™ in action.

Most people stay inside the lines. Follow the expected path. Click the obvious buttons. Accept things as they are.

Not you.

You’re one of those rare minds that refuses to accept “this is how it’s always been done.”

We need more people who think like you.

So here’s your reward for coloring outside the lines:

Get VIP pre-release access to the next assessment on Innovational Intelligence™:

You’ll be the first to know when it’s available.

Keep breaking rules. The world needs what you see.

Your daily dose (or almost) of Innovational Intelligence™!

Receive in your inbox my latest post before everyone else!